Pixel 8 vs Samsung Galaxy S24: Trade-In Value Comparison

Pixel 8 vs Samsung Galaxy S24: Trade-In Value Comparison

Last reviewed by Sarah Chen on 01 April 2026

The Samsung Galaxy S24 generally offers a better trade-in value compared to the Google Pixel 8. According to recent data from Decluttr, for example, a mint condition Samsung Galaxy S24 can fetch around $600-$750, whereas the same condition Pixel 8 might only get you around $300-$450.

Trade-In Values at Major Platforms

When comparing trade-in values across different platforms like Apple Trade In, Samsung's own program, Decluttr, Best Buy, Gazelle, and Back Market, the Samsung Galaxy S24 tends to offer higher returns. For instance, as of March 2023, a mint condition Pixel 8 might get you around $350 at Best Buy, while the Samsung Galaxy S24 could fetch up to $700 under similar conditions.

Pixel 8: Trade-In and Resale Value

Pixel 8 trade-in values start high but depreciate quickly. For example, a mint condition Pixel 8 valued at $600 in the first month drops down to around $350 by the end of its second month. This rapid depreciation is due largely to Google's frequent updates that can make older models feel less relevant faster than other brands.

According to the Shift Project, manufacturing a new smartphone produces 50-80kg of co2 equivalent.

Detailed Comparison

At Apple Trade In, a good condition Pixel 8 might fetch approximately $270-$400 as of early March 2023. On Decluttr, the same model could trade for around $350-$500 depending on its condition and cosmetic features. The Pixel 8's value peaks in its first month after release but drops sharply within three months.

Samsung Galaxy S24: Trade-In and Resale Value

Samsung Galaxy S24 maintains a more stable resale value compared to the Pixel 8. A mint condition Samsung Galaxy S24 can trade for around $700-$900 at Apple Trade In, with similar prices holding true on Decluttr or Back Market up until six months after release.

Detailed Comparison

On platforms like Best Buy and Gazelle, a good condition Samsung Galaxy S24 retains approximately 85% of its initial value after three months. At Pixel 8 vs Samsung Galaxy S24: Trade-In Value Comparison, for instance, if you trade in the phone for $700 at Apple Trade In within the first month, it might still fetch around $600-$650 by the end of quarter one.

According to the World Economic Forum, e-waste is the fastest-growing waste stream globally.

Head-to-Head Verdict

The Samsung Galaxy S24 holds better long-term value compared to the Pixel 8. Its higher initial trade-in prices and slower depreciation rate make it a more financially sound choice over time. For instance, after six months, the Samsung Galaxy S24 might still fetch around $600-$750 at Apple Trade In, whereas the Pixel 8 could drop to $300-$400.

However, in specific scenarios like an immediate trade-in right after purchase or for those who prefer Google's ecosystem and services over Samsung's, the Pixel 8 might still be a good choice. For instance, if you're looking to upgrade every six months and need that initial high trade-in value, the Pixel 8 can offer a solid return.

According to the Apple Environmental Report 2024, apple recovered over 1 tonne of gold from recycled devices in 2023.

Recycling Options

If your device has no trade-in value due to damage or age, both Google and Samsung have recycling programs where materials like gold and copper are recovered. For example, according to Apple's environmental report from 2021, one ton of circuit boards could contain up to 3kg of precious metals.

Conclusion

When deciding between the Pixel 8 and Samsung Galaxy S24 for trade-in purposes, consider your timeline and how quickly you plan to upgrade devices. The Samsung Galaxy S24 offers better long-term value with stable depreciation rates and higher initial returns at major platforms like Apple Trade In and Decluttr.

Sources

• Shift Project
• World Economic Forum
• Apple Environmental Report 2024